How to make a thoughtful call when a package is lost, delayed or damaged — without losing sight of the customer or the claim
When peak-season shipping volume picks up, so does the number of decisions your team has to make.
You already know you want to take care of the customer when a package goes missing or arrives damaged. The harder part is deciding what that response should look like when you may not yet know where the package is, whether it will eventually arrive or how easily the order can be replaced.
Sometimes sending another item is the most sensible answer. Sometimes a refund brings the cleanest resolution. And sometimes waiting a little longer is worth it, especially when tracking suggests the original shipment may still be moving.
There isn’t one answer that works every time. The right choice usually comes down to what solves the customer’s problem without creating an unnecessary second problem for your business.
Before you decide, look at three things
When the pressure is on, it helps to have a light framework for making the right call. We think most reship-or-refund decisions can be narrowed by looking at three factors: urgency, shipment status and replaceability.
How urgently does the customer need the order?
Start with what the customer actually needs now.
If the item was meant for a specific event, deadline or holiday, a replacement arriving next week may no longer solve the problem. A refund could be the better answer.
If the customer still wants the product and another one can reach them in time, reshipping may preserve the sale and the relationship.
This is also why it helps to ask rather than assume. A customer who is willing to wait gives you more options than one whose deadline has already passed.
How likely is the original package to arrive?
A package that is clearly lost creates a different decision from one that is still showing movement in tracking.
Before sending another item, review the tracking history, confirm the address and look for delivery attempts, exceptions or other updates. If the package cannot be located, contact the carrier and begin the appropriate investigation. You may hear this called a tracer, which is simply the carrier’s process for investigating a missing shipment and determining what may have happened to it.
The more likely the original package is to arrive, the more important it becomes to think through what happens if you send a second one. You could end up with two products at the customer’s door and another return to manage.
How easily can the item be replaced?
Inventory changes the equation. If another unit is readily available and the cost of replacing it is manageable, reshipping may be an easy decision. If the product is customized, high-value, in short supply or difficult to source, it may make sense to gather more information before committing another unit.
Replacement cost also goes beyond the postage. A second shipment ties up more merchandise, incurs another shipping charge and may create additional work if the first package eventually arrives.
Taken together, these three questions give you a much clearer place to start.
So, when should you reship, refund or wait?
There still won’t be a formula that works for every business, but the decision becomes easier once you know what you’re trying to solve.
Reshipping may make sense when the customer still needs the item, inventory is available and another shipment can resolve the problem without creating disproportionate cost or complexity.
A refund may make more sense when the customer no longer needs the order, its useful delivery window has passed or replacing it is impractical.
Waiting may be reasonable when tracking still gives you a credible reason to believe the package will arrive and the customer has enough flexibility to give it more time.
The point is not to create a rigid rule for every shipment. It’s to give your team a consistent way to arrive at the right decision.
Move quickly, but keep the record intact
Once you decide how to help the customer, it can be tempting to close the loop and move on. Before you do, make sure you’ve saved the information that may be harder to recover later.
For a missing package, keep the tracking history, original order information and any carrier investigation details together. If merchandise arrives damaged, ask the customer to photograph the item, the outside of the box, the internal packaging and the shipping label before anything is returned or discarded. They should also keep the damaged merchandise and original packaging in case the carrier may need to review or inspect them.
That request is worth making early. Once the packaging is gone, recreating what the shipment looked like when it arrived may be impossible.
And if you refund the order or send a replacement, keep the records from the original shipment intact. Helping the customer and documenting what happened to the shipment can move forward at the same time.
Talk through the decision before you have to make it
Some of this may sound like common sense, and in many ways it is. But common sense can be harder to apply consistently when a customer is waiting, tracking is clear and several employees may be involved. What seems obvious to one person may not be obvious to the next.
That’s why it’s worth talking through these decisions before peak season puts them in front of you.
Decide who can authorize a replacement or refund and when a higher-value order deserves another set of eyes. Consider how long your team is generally comfortable waiting on stalled tracking before escalating to the carrier, and which products are difficult enough to replace that you’d want more information before sending another one.
It also helps to agree on what should happen before damaged merchandise is returned or discarded, and who steps in when the usual employee handling these issues is unavailable.
None of this needs to become a rigid policy. The circumstances will change from one shipment to the next, but over time, you may notice that certain situations keep leading to the same decisions or the same complications. Those are useful signals that your process may be worth adjusting before the next busy period.
The more your team has thought through while things are running smoothly, the less it has to figure out in the moment.
When delivery is unpredictable, your response doesn’t have to be
There will always be some uncertainty when a shipment goes missing or arrives damaged. Tracking may not tell the whole story, the customer may need an answer before the carrier has one and the best response may change from one order to the next. What you can control is how thoughtfully you make the call.
Knowing which questions matter — how urgently the customer needs the item, how likely the original shipment is to arrive and how difficult it would be to replace — gives your team a better way to respond without defaulting to the fastest or most familiar option.
You may still decide to reship. You may refund. You may wait. But the decision is no longer just a reaction to a shipping problem. It’s a considered response to what the customer and the business actually need.
This material has been prepared for general informational purposes only, is intended to apply generally rather than to any specific company and presumes appropriate discretion will be exercised regarding any particular situation.
©2026 Copyright Parcel Insurance Plan. All Rights Reserved.
Parcel Insurance Agency | CA License #0D85835

